Qwen3.8 27B addition in words

星海拾光AI 前沿📡 Simon Willison's Weblog2026-10-061188 阅读💛 21 收藏

Research: Qwen3.8 27B addition in words

Colin Frasier posted on Bluesky about an experiment he ran over two years ago using GPT-4o to see how well it could "compute the sum but return the answer in words" across increasingly large numbers. Here's the chart he shared of those results:

I'm confident GPT-4o didn't cheat and use a calculator, especially since it got so many of the calculations wrong, but I was inspired to run the experiment again on local hardware (a DGX Spark) to explore the effect in a fully controlled environment.

I pasted his image into a Codex Remote session (GPT-6 Astra) and had it run the same experiment using Qwen3.8-27B-Q4_K_M.gguf . Here's the result for a run of 30 attempts per combination with reasoning disabled:

Then I ran it again with reasoning enabled. This took a lot longer per pair, so instead of running 30 samples per square I ran just one - which results in a much less visually appealing heatmap since each square is either 100% or 0%:

It got the right answer in 167 out of 169 attempts, and since these were one-shot I'm confident a second run would produce different results here.

Here's a version of the report that includes the reasoning traces from some of those larger calculations, which include text like this:

Wait, let me redo this more carefully.

4,299,366,105,622

6,088,794,067,970

Let me align them:

4 2 9 9 3 6 6 1 0 5 6 2 2

6 0 8 8 7 9 4 0 6 7 9 7 0

Adding from right to left:

Position 1 (units): 2 + 0 = 2

Position 2 (tens): 2 + 7 = 9

Position 3 (hundreds): 6 + 9 = 15, write 5, carry 1

Tags: mathematics , ai , generative-ai , local-llms , llms , qwen , llm-reasoning , dgx-spark

文章评论(12)

墨沐雨18 小时前

楼主辛苦了,内容很有参考价值。

回复
星寻梦19 小时前

思路清晰,干货满满。

回复
林观澜20 小时前

支持作者,持续关注中。

回复
星寻梦18 小时前

点赞,必须点赞

回复
暮临风19 小时前

整理得太全面了,省了我不少时间。

回复
三分糖去冰18 小时前

这个比较实用,已转发给同事。

回复
星寻梦19 小时前

点赞,必须点赞

回复
风倚栏16 小时前

收藏了,以后慢慢研究。

回复
星寻梦18 小时前

这个比较实用,已转发给同事。

回复
雪影17 小时前

收藏了,以后慢慢研究。

回复
拾贝者15 小时前

实测过类似工具,作者说的基本属实。

回复
墨向阳18 小时前

作者写得真不错,学到了不少。

回复